Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Paul Snyder's avatar

Well said…

Perhaps being from Jersey and of Cuban heritage, you know something of the history of Wash Heights in NYC.

I moved to NYC from Vegas in the late 1970’s because… punk guitarist and all. Seemed like a good idea at the time. 😑

Ended up in Wash Heights because one could get a fairly large rehearsal space for super cheap.

The whole NYC economic thing was cratering at the time. WH was undergoing substantial demographic shifts while simultaneously dealing with NYC expiring in an economic sense. I mean, it was really bad. The type and degree of “badness” evolved in the 1980s, though I had moved on by that point.

In relation to your post, tribal divisions between various elements all got worse as the economic situation collapsed. For whatever reason, a lot of the local economic hierarchy was dominated by Cubans (obviously, they weren’t an absolutely dominant force in business and property development, but so far as a “minority” population went… they were a power block in WH).

If one was part of the Black spillover from Harlem at the time… the word was that attempting to deal with Cuban owners was a waste of time, and the “paler” the Cuban, the more so.

The Dominican community was well established in WH, though also in ascendance. From what I, white boy that I be, understood… their DR system was more complicated due to the residual aftershocks following DR conflicts in the 1960s (Right vs Left, with more Lefties heading to NYC). In most every aspect, though, the DR community still held true to stratification and economic sorting by how Spanish one appeared. The more Taino characteristics were exhibited, the lower one was assumed to be in social standing, education, capacity for advancement, etc.

As the employment situation got worse in WH, the racial issues became more apparent. The “In” groups could maintain employment and housing for their tribe. The “Out” groups (Harlem spillover Blacks, Black Dominicans, etc.) got sent to Jersey for employment and eventually housing.

The world provided me with a more brutal example of this concept when, in the 1990’s I went down to Haiti a few times. First for music research and as a “back door” route into Cuba, then for aid logistics management.

Turns out WH was just a vastly watered down model of Hispaniola. I knew there were racial and colonial holdover divisions down there, but to be… again… the white boy that could bounce over borders and be exposed to the unadulterated views of many Dominicans (not all, but I interpreted it as a vast majority). Their views regarding Haitians were pretty jaw dropping, bordering upon genocidal wishes. Once again, the higher on the economic ladder the Dominican, the more “Conservative” they were and the greater the loathing of all things Haitian.

I continue to believe that Marx’s concept of “Primitive Accumulation of Capital” is the best causal explanation for our situations in the western world, and the exacerbation of macro and micro “racial” divisions and subdivisions based on whether you look like the historic accumulators or those who were forced to be subordinate to those accumulators.

I have yet to experience an environment that disabuses e of that belief. Maybe one exists out there, but I haven’t lived in it.

Thanks again for your efforts.

All the best and congrats on your increased following and professional acknowledgment.

Expand full comment
𝓙𝓪𝓼𝓶𝓲𝓷𝓮 𝓦𝓸𝓵𝓯𝓮's avatar

Honestly, we need to stop using colonizer words too. Culture and race are bullshit divisions. We're all one species. Rabbits in China don't have a different "culture" than rabbits in Spain. Nationalism is another colonizer idea.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts